Woodshedding the Schumann Op 102 mv. 2 (langsam)

Today was primarily listening carefully with a tuner to the harmonic section, particularly the e-f-g-a upbow in m. 52 and 3.   Just repetitive until I get it in tune and hear it in tune.

Still thinking about what the song actually means to me.  I tend to interpret it as a call-and-response good-bye song, with the person being left starts out angry and gets progressively more accepting and melancholy as it progresses.   I honestly don’t know what the right music history or theory is. . Although it could also be a lullaby.

I’m currently reading a biography of Schumann to try to put this all in contextMore on history and meaning coming up, but don’t spoil it for me since I need to do my own research.


New Pieces, New Teacher!

Chord Progression

Chords: G-C-Am-F#dim-D-Bm-G-Gm-D-F#dim-[??]-G

  • Don’t stay on an etude forever.
  • New Chord Exercises
  • Memorizing pieces is worth doing

The new teacher is also a Bloomsburg Preparatory School of Music teacher, as was my previous.  I tend to say very little specific about my teachers to respect their privacy.  I try to limit my comments to their approach to my teaching.

The new pieces and my progress on them:

New Etude: A chord progression exercise from a textbook hopefully my readers can recognize.  Spent several hours on this, and still having problems with my LH position.

New Schroeder Etude: #19, a/k/a Lee Op. 70, #21.   Worked some – identified trouble spots, still learning notes

I think the only current piece that I’m not changing is the Suzuki.  I didn’t work on that this week, but I think the chord tuning exercises will help there, since my main trouble spot is keeping the chords in tune.

Mooney – moved to the section on extended second position, Ballad.  Did not work on that this week except for a quick run-through.

Schumann: Worked the most on this, with a goal of memorizing by the end of May.  Once that is done, my plan is to read the score along with the piano part rather than the cello marked score.  Finally, no reading at all.  That should have me ready for the recital in August.  I will talk more about the memorization in the upcoming posts.

I used the Wolfram Alpha Chord interface on when I couldn’t recognize a chord.
(Example – link opens new tab). I must confess a great deal of mystery involving chords.

Does anybody recognize the excerpt above?

How do the ear and brain figure out what a chord is when it’s not in root position?




So, my teacher tells me in the nicest cello-teacher way he can that I’m not making enough progress on or working hard enough on my Schroeder Etude. Translation, “what the f___ are you doing all week.”

Some of this has to do with being ready to practice before I practice, and that means having my tuner and metronome nearby. I am never good at sticking with the Metronome.  After about 3 measures, I start losing the beat, then I start beating myself up.

It would also help if I logged more carefully how much time I spend on each piece.

The way I’ve been managing my time is to push ahead and focus on one thing all week, and on the other things, just stay constant.   But looking at the results,  I need to give all my pieces roughly equal attention without prioritizing them.  However, I am concerned about my time management because I have both my pieces and my orchestra pieces.

With both my pieces and my orchestra pieces to study, and this dictates about 2 hours a day with about one hour and fifteen minutes for lesson work and the remainder for orchestra.  Therefore, I need to put aside my goal of moving up to the next level of Orchestra.  I can live with that over a one-year horizon.I may not be able to make it, but if I keep records, I can at least look at the results in more detail and decide

I may not be able to achieve my goal, but if I keep records, I can at least look at the results in more detail and decide by how much.  Then work to see what I can accomplish with the time I have.

So, what are my goals?

  1. Schumann “5 Pieces in Folk Style, II, Langsam”, ready for the recital in August.
  2. Finish Suzuki book 2 by December
  3. Be ready for CelloSpeak Skill Builder workshop in late July


Pieces Update



On both the Suzuki and the Schroeder, I need to keep my left hand in a shape and minimize finger movement.   Chords need to be tuned.  This is new to me, although I do understand what it means to tune a double stop, so perhaps I can generalize.  Once the chords are tuned, this should help the triplets in the Suzuki (Witches’ Dance).

I realize nobody reads these anymore, but I found it keep writing these for my own benefit. It is helpful to review my notes on past pieces to see what I worked on and what progress has been made.


Mid-Winter 2017


, , , , , , ,

Got some new pieces today.  Interesting that my own assessment of how I was doing was negative and my cello teacher’s was more positives.  We both noticed the same things, but he gave the problems less weight.

A-flat major scale (Klengel)

Positives: Playing the A-flat major scale more confidently and on tempo.  Continue using the metronome.  Using ear rather than hand and self-correcting.

Still work on: Descending shifts.

Mooney: Invisible Target (2d position exercise)

– just started.  No assessment. Not even sure why it’s called that.  I’ll guess I will ask.

Witches Dance (suzuki Book 2)

I need to find previous blog entries and re-tag them.  I’m still woodshedding this piece. working primarily with the metronome.

Lee Op. 70 No 20 (Schroeder #18)

“point” just means start near the point.  I need not have played the entire thing so close to the tip.  Focus on a light sound.   For LH, on measure 4, use separate strings (1 on I, 234 on II) and avoid too much hand-flapping.

Life in general:

Start a new job near Philly on the 27th.  Excited, but nervous.  Still working out living arrangements.  Will keep my current residence, but seek out semi-permanent arrangements in Philly’s suburbs.   Looking forward to perhaps catching some Curtis performances in the evenings when I can, even though my primary purpose down there will be work.





First Lesson of 2017

I started this blog with the goal of practicing every single day as a way to atone for starting later in life, and see how far it got me.    I am still further behind than I want, but I have different goals now that I have experienced ensemble playing.   My goal of playing competently by retirement seems reasonable.

Here’s today’s lesson:

Bach March in G: 

In some sections, particular m. 19, I am playing quarter notes as eighth notes.  I see the run of eighths coming up, and I get excited.  Metronome it out and play the same measure over and over.

Practical Tip: Consider hooking my metronome up to some speakers via an aux cord.  Then I have a better chance of hearing it over the cello.  I noticed when Nelson kept a really loud beat, I could stay with it.

Update: I tried this.  It worked pretty well, and for some reason having the metronome farther from me physically also gave me the patience to sit and get used to the beat.

A-flat major scale (2 octave):

Keep working at it with no peeking at the left hand, and a steady tempo.  Scale degrees are improving in general.   I’m still going to rely on one gliss to find C(I).  Try to get rid of that, but one thing at a time!

Schroeder #17:

It just sucks. Use the same tip regarding the metronome.   First, get the first beat on the first click, then refine to get the second beat.  Hopefully,  the third will solve itself. Try playing one or two measures over and over. Bow hand is working nicely, though.


8th Cello Birthday & Goals


Not much going on with lessons since I had a week of virtually no practice except for scales and my Schroeder.   Sometimes, I feel too guilty to practice, but that can be solved by putting my practice time  on my calendar like an appointment.  It currently is not done this way, so no wonder I’m getting the results I am.  Concert pieces are getting a run through once per day.  But now is the time to learn them cold.

Also, I’m going to have to get a black concert suit. Not what I wanted to do until I lost enough weight.  Going to be hard to set aside some time tomorrow to do this.

Moving from dietary to cello goals.  I’m coming up on eight years of cello playing, and I feel like I don’t have eight years to show for it.   I’m still in book 2, for example.  However, Sight Reading and general musicianship have improved considerably, as has my ensemble playing in the past year.  Nelson Berger, who is my teacher at Bloomsburg Preparatory Music School has helped me by stressing internal pulse and developing my ear as equal to technique.  Kelli Bertenshaw, who runs the ensembles gets credit too,but that will be another post where I can discuss in detail.

Anyway – the cello birthday is usually observed on Dec 1, which is the 8th anniversary of my first lesson with Dan Delaney. On to the goals, which are as follows:

  1. Complete Suzuki book two by mid-2017.
  2. Continue to build sight-reading by adding solfege and singing practice.  We discovered my vocal span is roughly from D2 to E3.
  3. Have the #2 ‘Langsam’ section of Schumann’s Five Pieces in Folk Style prepared for August 2017 recital.
  4. Have money saved to attend Cellospeak at Bryn Mawr this year.

As for today’s lesson, since not much progress could be made on the pieces, we worked on softening that bow hold and using the smoother bow on the etude.  The A major scale p from B on II to C on I is getting better.



Lesson Update


, , , ,

I think the pieces have improved, but there is still work to be done.

Lee op 70 no 11 (Schroeder #17)

Tempo is getting better, but try getting more to the tip of the bow.  Listen to the tone. Also, watch that D for intonation.  I start off well, but tend to lose attention.

Bach March in G

Metronome.  Enough said.  I really want to be done with this piece.  But that may be because I haven’t brought enough out of it yet.

A-flat Major scale

Listen for the intervals between B-flat and C.  Also, make sure C and D-flat have fingers closer the together than I thought.






Question: Fair Use

If I post videos of me practicing certain pieces and/or etudes and offering commentary on where I am with the piece, would that be considered fair use?

  1. It is primarily educational
  2. There is sufficient transformative content; I wouldn’t simply be putting a performance up, and I use the term generously as it is.
  3. It certainly wouldn’t discourage people from buying the real product 🙂 – that is it will likely be noticeably flawed.`

If all else fails,I could always just post excerpts.




Lesson Update 10/15

Lee Op 70 No 11:
Watch intonation on D4 (D4=D above middle C) .  Tune to open D periodically to check intonation. In this entire piece, there is no reasaon to ever move the LH out of first position.  Therefore, if I can keep the LH steady  without extraneous movement, I should stay in tune.

Therefore, tonight instead of looking at the music, I practiced watching my LH in the mirror to try to give feedback to the LH.


Try tricky m. 4 several times.  If I get to the tip, I  will likely not try to cheat the rhythm when you I find myself in a spot.  Use a fast bow to cover the entire bow in the first quarter note, but not louder.

General Left Hand

Can be 1 and 2 can be closer together than you think – same with 3 and 4.  The LH fingers are not supposed to be uniformly spaced.